Skip to main content

On coercion and consent:Rearranging regulations in mental-health practices (CONTRAST)

ANR contract (2013-2016) | Cermes3
Coordinators: Livia Velpry, Cermes3; Benoit Eyraud, Lyon2/Centre MaxWeber

In the past few decades, the legal, administrative, and ethical rules governing professional care practices have given the principle of consent greater importance in the health, social, and medical-social sectors.This evolution has changed the forms taken by coercion in care and the significance of its practice.These rearrangements in the framework of care practices affect the jurisdictional authorities that formulate and officially apply the principles, as well as affect the actors-in-situation facing moral dilemmas that they solve discreetly.These changes redistribute the boundaries between practices that are valued and those related to the “dirty work” and in doing so, raise important social issues at the intersection of civic concern for individual freedom and more social civic concern for the protection of individuals.

To clarify these issues, the CONTRAST project analyzes the regulations of care practices across different sectors of public action by observing how the various formalized, legal, ethical, and professional-ethics rules highlighting the principle of consent in care practices are applied, or not, in concrete situation.

We make the assumption that these regulations exist not only in the jurisdictional formulation of principles, but also in the ways of accounting for or discretely maintaining the forms of coercion entailed by care practices.To develop this assumption, the project articulates an original theoretical approach to regulations with an extended comparison of care practices in contrasted legal and ethical contexts.

Copyright © 2024 Cermes3

Centre de recherche, médecine, sciences, santé, santé mentale, société
UMR CNRS 8211 - Unité Inserm 988 - EHESS - Université Paris Cité
 This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Campus CNRS

7, rue Guy Môquet - BP 8
94801 Villejuif Cedex

Université Paris Cité

Campus Saint-Germain-des-Prés

Bâtiment Jacob (3ème étage)
45, rue des Saints-Pères
75270 Paris Cedex 06

logo inserm   logo cnrs logo universite parislogo ehess